The Economy Shoe Shop
http://www.economyshoeshop.ca/
My wife and I went down to The Economy Shoe Shop on Saturday evening for a night out. My wife wanted to check it out after seeing it being rated #1 in a couple of categories in The Coast surveys. (best place for a first date, ambience, and nachos).
We took up one of those #1's and ordered the nachos, which took quite a while to get to the table, but I would say they definitely deserve the ranking (and the wait). The rest of the menu looked really tasty as well (see the link to the website), and they had a great list of beers on tap as well as a good wine list.
The ambience is top notch, and because the Shoe Shop is actually one of 4 interconnected bars/restaurants connected together, you can pretty much find what you want. The Shoe Shop itself is definitely a more intimate atmosphere, with low lighting and most of the tables are set up for 2 people.
Since you're in the heart of Halifax's downtown, there's plenty to find once you're finished there as well, although we were disappointed that the Uncommon Grounds was closed as we wanted to grab a coffee when we left.
Anyway, I'd highly reccomend it, and hope to head back myself sometime to check out the rest of the menu.